Suburban Panic!

24 April 2008

I Was Not Aware Of That

  Three things I did not know:

1.  Dr. Henry Heimlich, purported inventor of the famed and (I shit you not) registered trademark "maneuver" for rescuing choking victims is still alive.

  I don't know why, but I always assumed that such a simple procedure must have been invented in the 19th century. Based on the last name, I pictured a humble Bavarian physician, decked out in lederhosen and suspenders. While knocking back a pint at a rural ale house, he rushed to the aid of one of the town volk who was choking on a bit of bratwurst. Thanks to his quick thinking, his technique became the namesake maneuver, and his improvised flailings (and maybe the bit of horked-up sausage) were preserved for posterity.

  As it turns out, the maneuver was first described in the mid-70s. Although it is still taught as a remedy for choking, it isn't the recommended first treatment. Dr. Heimlich was born in Delaware in 1920, and doesn't seem to be particularly humble. Or Bavarian.

2.  Dr. Heimlich has been dogged by allegations of fraud.

  One of Dr. Heimlich's most persistent critics is his son, Peter Heimlich. Among the allegations he levels against his father is the charge that the famous technique was appropriated from Dr. Heimlich's long time colleague, Dr. Edward Patrick.

3.  Dr. Heimlich may be completely, dangerously, batshit insane.

  Dr. Heimlich advocates the use of his system of abdominal thrusts to treat drowning victims, despite much evidence that such use is dangerous and potentially fatal. Most obviously crazy, though, is his insistence that he can cure HIV/AIDS with an injection. Of malaria.

  Dr. Heimlich, who has no training as an immunologist, seriously believes that he can cure AIDS, as well as cancer and Lyme disease, by injecting patients with malaria. In support of this hypothesis, he's conducted ethically suspect trials with HIV patients in China and Africa. One of the conditions of those trials was that participants couldn't receive any other treatment, either for their HIV or the symptoms of their malaria infections.

  This is what I get for relying on Eddie Izzard for information about a public figure.



I'm not about to say that my hour of casual reading amounts to a definitive case, but there is a good bit of evidence of a disconnect between Dr. Heimlich's self-promoted legacy and the details of his actual career in public health. If you think I'm wrong, feel free to argue.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

LBB - Since you're in Philly, did you ever see this 2004 Philadelphia Weekly article by Steve Volk, Scandal: Deadly Medicine?, about your local connection to the Heimlich story about a prominent local doctor named James Fattu, former president of the PA/Delaware chapter of the American Heart Association?

So let me ask you this, LBB. According to the article, Dr. Fattu is now shtum about his longstanding relationship with Dr. Patrick and his participation in developing the Heimlich maneuver. Would you contact Dr. Fattu, ask him why he's so shy about the subject, and post his response on your blog?

K.O. Myers said...

I hadn't read that article, Anonymous. It reinforces the perception that the "maneuver" has been, to say the least, overpromoted.

As interesting as this story is, I'm not a journalist. Blogging is a hobby. I don't have the time or resources to track down Dr. Fattu and convince him to be more forthcoming with me than he was with Steve Volk. Thanks for the tip, though.

Anonymous said...

I don't have the time or resources to track down Dr. Fattu

Looks like he's in the book.

Also stumbled upon this documentary about squatters in Philly, apparently made by Dr. Fattu's son. Maybe he should get together with Dr. Heimlich's son and compare notes!